VOTE FOR THE GIRLS with Ava Zinn and Alexandra Moffitt > American Idol > American Idol (season 14) > The Moderator Panel’s American Idol 14 Vote for the Worst Picks

The Moderator Panel’s American Idol 14 Vote for the Worst Picks

There is a reason why the Vote for the Girls main moderator panel’s eight moderators decided to decline Jax’s third place finish on American Idol, unfortunately leaving Nick Fradiani and Clark Beckham in the Top 2 and normally the competition ends  with a VFTG Loss.

However, since Nick Fradiani is the first male Vote for the Girls pick and had Clark finished third, an outright Vote for the Girls victory would have happened.

So the moderator panel decided to go with the dual winner format used on So You Think You Can Dance 9 and 10, and Jax being the female winner of American Idol 14 and Nick being the male __________ of American Idol 14. I think that should only be fair since next year will be the last season of American Idol, we will go with the two-winner format–a male winner and a female winner.

Top 24
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $35,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Rhonda Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL DEAL – $35,000
1 Sarina-Joi Crowe Shannon Mae Berthiaume
(ELIMINATED)
Maddie Walker (initially Jackie “JAX” Cole) Shania Scot
(ELIMINATED)
2 Loren Lott Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
Lovey James
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe
3 Lovey James
(ELIMINATED)
Maddie Walker Tyanna Jones Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
4 Adanna Duru Jackie “JAX” Cole Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
Alexis Gomez
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez Shannon Mae Berthiaume (initially Sarina-Joi Crowe)
(ELIMINATED)
Loren Lott
6 Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
Lovey James
(ELIMINATED)
Adanna Duru (initially Alexis Gomez) Maddie Walker
7 Maddie Walker Alexis Gomez
8 Alexis Gomez Sarina-Joi Crowe
9 Shannon Berthiaume
(ELIMINATED)
Jackie “JAX” Cole (initially Maddie Walker)
Best of Worst Riley Bria (Kymberly)
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe Loren Lott Lovey James
(ELIMINATED)
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Shania Scott
(ELIMINATED)
Jackie “JAX” Cole
Shania Scott (ELIMINATED) / Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Adam Ezegelian Riley Bria
(ELIMINATED)
Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer IMMUNITY IMMUNITY IMMUNITY IMMUNITY
1 Alexis Gomez Katherine Winston (ELIMINATED) Lovey James (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole (initially Maddie Walker)
2 Joey Cook Maddie Walker Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez
3 Katherine Winston (ELIMINATED) Alexis Gomez Sarina-Joi Crowe Shannon  Berthiaume (ELIMINATED)
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Riley Bria
(ELIMINATED)
Alexis Gomez Nick Fradiani
5 Loren Lott Lovey James
(ELIMINATED)
Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
Maddie Walker
6 Maddie Walker Sarina-Joi Crowe Maddie Walker Katherine Winston
(ELIMINATED)
7 Riley Bria
(ELIMINATED)
Shania Scott
(ELIMINATED)
Riley Bria
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe
8 Nick Fradiani
9 Sarina-Joi Crowe
Best of Worst Adanna Duru Shannon  Berthiaume (ELIMINATED) Tyanna Jones Lovey James (ELIMINATED)
Lovey James (ELIMINATED) Tyanna Jones (MOVED TO #1) Shania Scott(ELIMINATED) Riley Bria
(ELIMINATED)
VFTW Pick Trevor Douglas Haueisen
(ELIMINATED)
Tion Phipps
(ALREADY ELIMINATED)
Savion Wright
(ELIMINATED)
Cody Fry
(ALREADY ELIMINATED)

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Riley Bria (ELIMINATED) Savion Wright (ELIMINATED)
2 Clark Beckham Tion Phipps (ALREADY ELIMINATED)
3 Trevor Douglas Haueisen (ELIMINATED) Riley Bria (ELIMINATED)
4 Adam Ezegelian Michael Simeon (ELIMINATED)
5 Cody Fry (ALREADY ELIMINATED) Mark Andrew
6 Daniel Seavy Quassim Middleton

The Pink team’s moderators (Holly Everman, Kellie Rock, Tracia Ward, Lanise White, and Thia Tola) all earned immunity and got $50,000 after all their Vote for the Worst picks were eliminated.

Lanise White was suspended from the moderator panel upon seeing that Lovey James was not saved. Thia Tola filled in for Lanise White from the Top 16 to Final.


 

Top 16
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $30,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Rhonda Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL $35,000
1 Sarina-Joi Crowe Maddie Walker (initially Jackie “JAX” Cole)
2 Loren Lott
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe
3 Maddie Walker Tyanna Jones
4 Adanna Duru Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Loren Lott
(ELIMINATED)
6 Adanna Duru Maddie Walker
7 Maddie Walker Nick Fradiani Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Nick Fradiani
8 Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani Sarina-Joi Crowe Loren Lott
(ELIMINATED)
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Adanna Duru Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Adam Ezegelian
(ELIMINATED)
Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Maddie Walker Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
3 Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Sarina-Joi Crowe
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Alexis Gomez
(ELIMINATED)
Nick Fradiani
5 Loren Lott
(ELIMINATED)
Maddie Walker
6 Maddie Walker Sarina-Joi Crowe Maddie Walker
7 Sarina-Joi Crowe
8 Nick Fradiani
9 Sarina-Joi Crowe
Best of Worst Adanna Duru Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1
2 Clark Beckham
3
4 Adam Ezegelian (ELIMINATED)
5 Mark Andrew (ELIMINATED)
6 Daniel Seavy Quassim Middleton

 


 

Top 12
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $35,000

Rhonda Rhodes’ final appearance before her death.

Lanise White’s picks remained valid.

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Rhonda Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL $35,000
1 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED) Maddie Walker
2 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMININATED)
3 Maddie Walker Tyanna Jones
4 Adanna Duru Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6 Adanna Duru Maddie Walker
7 Maddie Walker Nick Fradiani Nick Fradiani
8 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED)
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED)
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Adanna Duru Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Maddie Walker Jackie “JAX” Cole
3 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED)
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5 Maddie Walker
6 Maddie Walker Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED) Maddie Walker
7 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED)
8 Nick Fradiani
9 Sarina-Joi Crowe (ELIMINATED)
Best of Worst Adanna Duru Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6 Daniel Seavy Quassim Middleton

 


 

Top 11
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $64,000

Tricia Rhodes, the widow of Rhonda Rhodes, filled in for the remainder of the competition following Rhonda’s death on March 15, 2015.

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL $35,000
1 Maddie Walker
2
3 Maddie Walker Tyanna Jones
4 Adanna Duru Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6 Adanna Duru Maddie Walker
7 Maddie Walker Nick Fradiani Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Adanna Duru Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Maddie Walker Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5 Maddie Walker
6 Maddie Walker Maddie Walker
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Adanna Duru Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6 Daniel Seavy Quassim Middleton

 


 

Top 11 Redux
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $54,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL DEAL $35,000
1 Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED)
2
3 Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED) Tyanna Jones
4 Adanna Duru (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6 Adanna Duru (ELIMINATED) Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED)
7 Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED) Nick Fradiani Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Adanna Duru (ELIMINATED) Nick Fradiani Adanna Duru (ELIMINATED)
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5 Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED)
6 Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED) Maddie Walker (ELIMINATED)
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Adanna Duru (ELIMINATED) Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6 Daniel Seavy Quassim Middleton

 


 

Top 9
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $25,000

Thia Tola’s primary pick of Daniel Seavey lasted four weeks.

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $35,000
1
2
3 Tyanna Jones
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Quassim Middleton
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen Daniel Seavey (ELIMINATED)
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6 Daniel Seavy (ELIMINATED) Quassim Middleton

 


 

Top 8
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $22,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $35,000
1
2
3 Tyanna Jones
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Joey Cook (Ava) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham Quassim Middleton (ELIMINATED)
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer DEAL $22,000
IMMUNITY $50,000
NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6 Quassim Middleton (ELIMINATED)

 


 

Top 7
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $38,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $36,000
1
2
3 Tyanna Jones
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Joey Cook (Ava-ELIMINATED) Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham
Quentin Aleander Rayvon Owen
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer $72,000 NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Joey Cook (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6

 


 

Top 6
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $27,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $35,000
1
2
3 Tyanna Jones
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani & Ariana Gavrils
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham
Quentin Aleander (ELIMINATED) Rayvon Owen
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer $72,000 NO DEAL NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Tyanna Jones
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Quentin Alexader (ELIMINATED) Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6

 


 

Top 5
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $100,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $35,000
1
2
3 Tyanna Jones (ELIMINATED)
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst Nick Fradiani
Tyanna Jones (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham
Rayvon Owen
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer $72,000 DEAL $100,000
IMMUNITY $50,000
NO DEAL NO DEAL
1 Tyanna Jones (ELIMINATED) Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst Tyanna Jones (ELIMINATED)
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Rayvon Owen
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6

 


 

Top 4
MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $70,000

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER NO DEAL NO DEAL $54,000 $36,000
1 Nick Fradiani
2
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole
6
7 Nick Fradiani
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole
Best of Worst
Jackie “JAX” Cole
Nick Fradiani
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham
Rayvon Owen (ELIMINATED)
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer $72,000 $150,000 NO DEAL DEAL $130,000
IMMUNITY $50,000
1 Jackie “JAX” Cole
2 Jackie “JAX” Cole
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole Nick Fradiani
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani
9
Best of Worst
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1 Rayvon Owen (ELIMINTED)
2 Clark Beckham
3
4
5
6

 


 

Top 3 (FINALE)
FINAL MALE MODERATOR’S OFFER: $130,000

MODERATOR’S SAVE: Jax and Nick

MALE WINNER: Nick Fradiani (winner of merican Idol 14)
FEMALE WINNER: Jax Cole  (finished 3rd on American Idol 14)

WINNING MODERATORS: Ava Zinn, Kymberly Alvaraz, and Tracia Ward

Team Ava & Kymberly
(Ava Zinn & Kymberly Alvaraz)
Julia Passalt Kendra Ray Tricia Rhodes
MALE Moderator’s OFFER WINNING MODERATOR

($1,080,000)

$0 $129,000 $35,000
1 Nick Fradiani (WINNER)
2
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
5 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
6
7 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
8
9 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
Best of Worst
Nick Fradiani (WINNER)
VFTW Pick Clark Beckham (Ava Only, RUNNER-UP)
Holly Everman Kellie Rock Lanise White Tracia Ward
Male Moderator’s Offer $72,000 $150,000 $0 WINNING MODERATOR

$1,180,000

1 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
2 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE)
3
4 Jackie “JAX” Cole (MODERATORS’ SAVE) Nick Fradiani (WINNER)
5
6
7
8 Nick Fradiani (WINNER)
9
Best of Worst
VFTW Pick

The Male Moderators:

Leonard Lai (The Tantrum Transman) Clark Jones (The Dark Beast)
1
2 Clark Beckham (RUNNER-UP)
3
4
5
6
Liked it? Take a second to support the webmaster Ava Zinn on Patreon!
This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.